Current:Home > InvestThe push for school choice in Nebraska is pitting lawmakers against their constituents -Trailblazer Capital Learning
The push for school choice in Nebraska is pitting lawmakers against their constituents
View
Date:2025-04-17 01:31:04
OMAHA, Neb. (AP) — Nebraska lawmakers are set for the first time to pass a bill that would block the public from voting on a ballot measure initiated by citizens of the state, setting up what could be a long battle over whether to fund private school tuition with public dollars.
On Thursday, lawmakers will take a final vote on a bill that would repeal a law passed last year to divert millions in income tax receipts to pay for private school scholarships. The bill would replace it with a measure that would directly fund private school tuition from state coffers. If it passes, it will effectively block voters from repealing the private school funding law that is set to appear on the November ballot following a successful petition drive.
Retired Lincoln high school teacher Rita Bennett described lawmakers’ plan to circumvent a vote of the people with one word.
“Outrage,” Bennett said.
The use of ballot initiatives has long been a source of pride not just for residents, but Nebraska’s unique one-chamber, nonpartisan legislature. Lawmakers often refer to the state’s residents as “the Nebraska Legislature’s second house.”
It’s why the move to “usurp the will of voters” is so audacious, said Bennett, a volunteer who collected petition signatures last summer to get the repeal question on the ballot.
“It’s quite chilling,” she said.
For Gretna resident Angie Lauritsen — who collected signatures last summer at county fairs, on sidewalks and by knocking on doors — the issue is personal. Her son was rejected from a private preschool because he was born with a condition that left him nonverbal until he was nearly 4, but through public school, he was given a specialist at the age of 2 and is now a talkative and thriving teen, she said.
“It’s about taking away the right of the people to vote,” Lauritsen said, noting that many people who signed mentioned being related to a public school teacher. “This is personal for a lot of people, not just me.”
The new bill is an “end-run” around the ballot initiative, said State Sen. Lou Ann Linehan, the author of last year’s law, during a public hearing. But it also gives a choice to families whose public school is not serving them well. A large portion of the private school scholarships would go to students who are being bullied, foster kids and students with a parent serving active military duty or had a parent killed in the line of duty, she said.
“This isn’t an anti-public schools bill,” she said recently during debate. “This is to give parents a choice. Why would we be against that?”
Anthony Schutz, a law professor at the University of Nebraska College of Law, testified against Linehan’s new bill to directly fund private school tuition, saying he believes it violates the Nebraska Constitution’s prohibition against appropriating public funds to nonpublic schools.
Opponents could try to launch another petition effort to ask voters to repeal the new bill this November, although they would have only weeks to gather enough signatures to meet a July deadline. Or they could sue, Schutz said.
“One line of argument is that it’s an appropriation to students and their parents, not a direct appropriation to private schools,” Schutz said.
But because the money can only be used for private school tuition, it might be difficult to convince a court, he said.
Linehan floated another argument earlier this year to try to convince Nebraska Secretary of State Bob Evnen to pull the repeal measure from the November ballot. Linehan held that the ballot initiative was unconstitutional because the state constitution places the power of taxation solely in the hands of the legislature.
Evnen ultimately found the ballot initiative to be legal, but acknowledged the issue was likely to be decided in court.
Asked whether the ballot initiative to repeal last year’s private school tuition scholarship law would remain on the November ballot or be pulled from it if Linehan’s new bill passes, Evnen’s office said it is consulting with the Nebraska Attorney General to make that decision.
Were the measure to remain on the ballot, it could prove a humbling rebuke if voters decide against public money going to private schools. Lauritsen said a good portion of the signatures she collected came from those who said they supported Linehan’s bill, but wanted to give “everybody a chance to vote on it.”
“At the end of the day, it’s an unprecedented use of legislation to cut off a referendum,” Schutz said. “It’s a politically difficult action to defend.”
Opponents of the bill say they’re ready for another fight.
“I stand ready to do whatever is necessary,” Bennett said. “If it means I’m out collecting signatures all summer, that’s where I’ll be.”
veryGood! (12688)
Related
- B.A. Parker is learning the banjo
- Pennsylvania chocolate factory fined for failing to evacuate before fatal natural gas explosion
- Tom Hanks: Don't fall for AI version of me promoting dental plan
- The Powerball jackpot is now $1.4 billion, the third highest in history. See Wednesday's winning numbers.
- 'We're reborn!' Gazans express joy at returning home to north
- Pair arrested in Massachusetts suspected in successful and attempted carjackings in New Hampshire
- Which team faces most pressure this NHL season? Bruins, Lightning have challenges
- These associate degree majors lead to higher incomes than a 4-year bachelor's. Here are the top programs.
- Questlove charts 50 years of SNL musical hits (and misses)
- The McRib returns: Here are the ingredients that make up the iconic sandwich
Ranking
- Moving abroad can be expensive: These 5 countries will 'pay' you to move there
- Pennsylvania House passes bill to move up presidential primary, but it has conflicts with the Senate
- Rolling candy sold nationwide recalled after death of 7-year-old
- Court dismisses $224 million verdict against Johnson & Johnson in talcum power lawsuit
- Will the 'Yellowstone' finale be the last episode? What we know about Season 6, spinoffs
- Trump moves to dismiss federal election interference case
- David Beckham Roasts Victoria Beckham Over Her Working Class Claim
- US regulators seek to compel Elon Musk to testify in their investigation of his Twitter acquisition
Recommendation
'No Good Deed': Who's the killer in the Netflix comedy? And will there be a Season 2?
Rep. George Santos’ former campaign treasurer will plead guilty to a federal felony, prosecutors say
These major cities have experienced the highest temperature increases in recent years
What Congress accomplished with McCarthy as speaker of the House
Realtor group picks top 10 housing hot spots for 2025: Did your city make the list?
How Travis Kelce's Mom Donna Is Shaking Off Haters Over Taylor Swift Buzz
US resumes some food aid deliveries to Ethiopia after assistance was halted over ‘widespread’ theft
Father weeps as 3 charged with murder in his toddler’s fentanyl death at NYC day care